| Platinum | DJs Collectibles |
| Gold | Geekrafter |
| Silver | North Bay Games & Hobbies |
| Bronze | Ultimate Sportscards |
| Top Pick | Creative Learning |
| Top Pick | Mike's Antiques and Toys |
| Top Pick | Mindgames |
| Top Pick | More Games More Hobbies |
| Top Pick | October's Meta |
| Top Pick | Outpost Gaming |