| Platinum | East Side Mario's |
| Gold | Greco's Pizza |
| Silver | Between the Bun |
| Bronze | The Wagon Wheel |
| Top Pick | 1886 Lake House Bistro |
| Top Pick | Farina Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars |
| Top Pick | Nonna's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Pasta Hostess |
| Top Pick | Station Tap House & Steak Co |