| Platinum | North Bay's Cupcake Queen |
| Gold | Milc Custom Cookies |
| Silver | All Things Lovely Cheesecake |
| Bronze | Opera Bakery Cafe |
| Top Pick | Between the Bun |
| Top Pick | Dinner is Served by Dianne's Catering |
| Top Pick | Elina's Homemade Desserts |
| Top Pick | Heather's Fudge |
| Top Pick | Manal's Baklava |
| Top Pick | Twiggs Coffee Roasters |