| Platinum | Sugarkiss Cookies |
| Gold | Milc Custom Cookies |
| Silver | North Bay's Cupcake Queen |
| Bronze | Between the Bun |
| Top Pick | Amandas Homemade Goodies |
| Top Pick | Anxious Bakers |
| Top Pick | Bay Barkery |
| Top Pick | Miss Keto's |
| Top Pick | Sweet Indulgence |
| Top Pick | The Culture Club |